Juan Roman Riquelme: Unfulfilled Genius

If Claude Makelele was one of the greatest over-achievers in the history of football; then Juan Roman Riquelme must unfortunately be regarded as a considerable under-achiever. Makelele made more of limited ability than any other player; Riquelme relatively little of instinctive footballing giftedness. During one match, against Serbia & Montenegro in the World Cup in Germany, Riquelme showcased more verve and inspiration than Makelele managed in his whole career. Unfortunately, what should have been a career-defining performance instead became a sad portent of what might have been for this somewhat wasted talent.

Blessed with the most natural appreciation of space and collective team movement I can recall before Barcelona redefined the art of possession football through Xavi and Iniesta, Riquelme dominated games with swagger and style at his peak despite his lack of physical gifts. Relying purely on his technical ability and football intelligence Riquelme was indisputably an artist at work in the beautiful game. Owning technique, balance, passing ability, imagination and a magisterial first touch – the Argentinian had it almost all.

A goal against Brazil in a World Cup qualifier encapsulated Riquelme’s imperious footballing ability. Prompting the move by controlling a Roberto Carlos clearance with an outrageous  back-heeled volley out to the right flank, Riquelme received the ball a couple of passes later, waltzed around one challenge and absolutely caned the ball into the top corner with his allegedly weaker foot. Similarly, while Cambiasso may have scored that famous goal against Serbia in Germany, it was completely owned by Riquelme’s passing, movement and opening of space.

Two truly glorious goals; but ones which possibly revealed more questions than answers about the delightful Riquelme. Why, with this immense natural talent, was Riquelme not able to harness it more consistently? Why were there only flashes throughout his career of the greatness that should have been automatic for such a footballing visionary?

Each of Riquelme’s major club honours were won on the continent of his birth for Boca Juniors. 3 Copa Libertadores trophies and 4 Argentinian League titles is a considerable weight of silver for an heir to Maradona’s revered Number 10 shirt at Boca. However, and this is a great shame, South American club football has been a veritable sporting backwater since the conception of the gargantuan, consuming Champions League. Institutions of the game like Boca and River Plate in Argentina; Sao Paulo and Santos in Brazil, lie crumbling due to this evil empire of greed and selfishness. It is against this backdrop of sporting imbalance that Riquelme has prospered; not exactly the top of the game – even for the most vehement defenders of Riquelme.

However, for one glorious half-season in 2006 Riquelme reached the heights that his natural talent demanded but even that career zenith was marred by two unfortunate moments. After single-handedly dragging his mediocre Villarreal team to the Champions League semi-finals Riquelme then missed a penalty in the closing moments of the second leg against Arsenal that would have taken the tie to extra-time.

The second moment was less Riquelme’s fault but tragically extinguished what was still threatening to be a great career. After effortlessly controlling the Argentinian team for the first four and a half matches of the World Cup, including his afore-mentioned masterpiece against Serbia, Riquelme was substituted with ten minutes left in the quarter-final against Germany. Leading 1-0 at the time, Argentina initially surrendered the initiative in the absence of Riquelme, and then the lead – Germany eventually going on to win on penalties. Despite his later resurrection back in Argentina with Boca Juniors, this act of ludicrous stupidity by Jose Pekerman was the death knell for any aspirations to immortality for Riquelme.

Riquelme could be viewed as a throwback player; had his career occurred in the ‘80s, or even the ‘90s, he might be regarded with the same appreciation as Roberto Mancini – a similarly languid maestro in possession. Unfortunately, the modern game with its emphasis on high tempo pressing and speed of movement contributed to Riquelme’s continued struggle to impose himself on European football during an unhappy spell at Barcelona and through five inconsistent years at Villarreal. While undoubtedly a gifted footballer, and his pinnacle in 2006 will live long in the memory, he should be regarded as the anti-Makelele – a genius whose potential remained unfulfilled.

Tagged , , , ,

5 thoughts on “Juan Roman Riquelme: Unfulfilled Genius

  1. M says:

    Need some more punctuation in places (mostly commas), but good. I loved Ricky, a joy to watch.

  2. beardedlady says:

    Even now, Riquelme looks light years ahead of evey other player on the pitch when it comes to vision and awareness.
    His performances for Boca this season in between injury have been a joy.

    Still my all time fav player.

  3. Nice piece; always love reading about Román. I suppose your basic premise is true, that Román never had a period in his career where he relentlessly dominated all-comers at the highest level. Then again, more than the individual moments of brilliance, it’s a rare player who can radically lift the level of his teammates so that they’re suddenly real contenders, Maradona-style. Even if he missed the penalty, his achievements at Villareal were remarkable. Same with his Libertadores win in 2007 – the standard may not be as consistently high as in Europe, but the Libertadores is a much more gruelling competition, and Román pissed on everyone. I think he even finished top scorer.

    2007 was his annus mirabilis. He took that form into the Copa América, where Argentina were genuinely sexy, thrilling and smart, before they were undone by Dunga’s thugs in the final. The last few games for Argentina in 2007 were also dominated by Román, his goals and assists leading to wins over Chile, Bolivia and Venezuela. That was the last time Argentina played well. The raggletag Argentina of the last few years with a Román-shaped hole in the middle has consistently failed to beat even Bolivia.

    I mention it more than anything else because I wonder, and your piece reminded me of it, what would have happened if Román hadn’t fought with Pellegrini after the World Cup in 2006. After all, that’s why he ended up back at Boca in 2007. Like Tevez, it was a mix of a capricious manager and a somewhat shall we say intransigent personality that saw him exiled from the top level of the game. If he’d been in Spain, England, Italy or whatever in 2007, i’m sure he’d have a few more Eurobaubles to his name.

    Having said that, though, I insist you can’t underestimate that Libertadores win in 2007. It was pure skill, pure will, like a vietcong amputating the inoculated arms of schoolchildren.

  4. Colin says:

    Hi Ali, nice article. I only really saw Riquelme when he was at Villarreal and also for Argentina, but whenever I did he was simply outstanding. I’m amazed he never really furthered his career or fulfilled the massive promise he had, but as an above comment says, winning the Libertadores is no mean feat.

    Probably one of the most underrated, undervalued and under-achieving players ever.

  5. H says:

    Great player. If only he had pace and consistency. Could have been amongst the best.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: